{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "artifact_id": "country-climate-intelligence-v1-multi-model-ai-review-2026-08-28", "status": "ai_factual_public_authorized", "review_type": "multi_model_ai", "human_review": false, "legal_certification": false, "independent_institutional_review": false, "publication_authority": { "authorized": true, "scope": "country_climate_intelligence_ai_factual_public_lane_only", "note": "Authority is limited to this exact AI-reviewed factual lane and remains contingent on the strict verifier and staged-integrity checks passing." }, "public_label": "AI-reviewed source-data release — source observations, estimates, modeled projections, reanalysis, and disclosed deterministic derivations; no human review or legal certification.", "subject": { "release_id": "country-climate-intelligence-2026-08-27-candidate.7", "review_request_path": "data/climate/releases/country-climate-intelligence-v1/review-request.json", "review_request_sha256": "0904afc65386a570871fdc77262a8beb6da8f19043a3d1f235edefd4f96d0372", "review_request_artifact_pin_digest": "3d044004953cd2d159a58e80384b969258611def6dca144c07f3816fe03e8200", "runtime_sha256": "4939fbc6e26c0ef0fc283ecf98ab3924ccb93d93b7e5392eab2014f7ab3c57fe", "registry_entity_count": 249, "metric_count": 26, "public_file_count": 51 }, "maintainer_authorization": { "authorized": true, "authorized_at": "2026-08-28T02:16:26Z", "policy": "ai_reviewed_source_data_publication", "scope": "country_climate_intelligence_v1_factual_source_data_surface", "human_review_substitute": false, "receipt": "The foundation maintainer explicitly authorized the separate AI-reviewed factual publication lane in the release task." }, "existing_human_signature_gate": "unchanged_and_unsatisfied", "aggregation_policy": { "rule": "No unresolved reviewer blocker may be overridden by a vote. Every condition must have a fail-closed implementation receipt before authorization.", "review_count": 4, "model_family_count": 3, "composition": "two Luna reviews, one Terra review, and one Sol review", "institutional_independence_claim": false }, "review_count": 4, "model_family_count": 3, "reviewers": [ { "reviewer_id": "ai-reviewer:luna-science", "provider": "OpenAI", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "role": "scientific_data_method", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-28T03:06:41Z", "scope": "Source semantics, formulas, evidence classes, derivations, gaps, and all 249 entity mappings.", "post_mitigation_verdict": "approve_with_conditions", "report": { "path": "data/climate/reviews/cci-v1-ai-reports/luna-science.md", "sha256": "caff5cf48a7f49b7dc1c66d78eacdd6b289ea60f8dc6b9b9918eb663f476a91f" } }, { "reviewer_id": "ai-reviewer:luna-rights", "provider": "OpenAI", "model": "gpt-5.6-luna", "role": "source_rights_attribution_provenance", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-28T03:04:16Z", "scope": "Source licence bases, attribution, excluded image assets, retained NASA/Natural Earth evidence, and public limitations.", "post_mitigation_verdict": "approve_with_conditions", "report": { "path": "data/climate/reviews/cci-v1-ai-reports/luna-rights.md", "sha256": "73930c6b4afc6e9801169ad4d5eb40a860ef33debb41d2ff3471399bcde1e095" } }, { "reviewer_id": "ai-reviewer:terra-runtime", "provider": "OpenAI", "model": "gpt-5.6-terra", "role": "runtime_accessibility_release_rails", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-28T03:07:23Z", "scope": "Deterministic public staging, runtime/fallback behavior, accessibility, cache coupling, rollback, and gate isolation.", "post_mitigation_verdict": "approve_with_conditions", "report": { "path": "data/climate/reviews/cci-v1-ai-reports/terra-runtime.md", "sha256": "640393a44ae146bec9f916393bd7c302c4e52ff322561072d4693873c1ccc246" } }, { "reviewer_id": "ai-reviewer:sol-red-team", "provider": "OpenAI", "model": "gpt-5.6-sol", "role": "final_adversarial_release_review", "reviewed_at": "2026-08-28T03:04:08Z", "scope": "Final adversarial review of the mitigated source subject, reports, aggregate, deployment surface, and legacy-gate isolation.", "post_mitigation_verdict": "approve_with_conditions", "report": { "path": "data/climate/reviews/cci-v1-ai-reports/sol-red-team.md", "sha256": "0b8369505ab2a550512b6e5cbd899e19cfc896e8ff5d88fe763d29af22c3b493" } } ], "publication_boundary": { "composite_score": false, "target_assessment": false, "finance_judgment": false, "performance_grade": false, "offset_adjustment": false, "mismatched_scope_comparison": false, "climate_trace_included": false, "inverted_carbon_relief_experiment": false }, "source_rights": [ { "id": "gcb", "source_registry_id": "gcp-gcb-2025-v1.0", "ai_reviewed_publication_decision": "allow_with_attribution", "licence_basis": "CC BY 4.0 on the ICOS/GCB 2025 v1.0 collection; DOI 10.18160/GCP-2025.", "required_attribution": "Global Carbon Project (2025), Supplemental data of Global Carbon Budget 2025, version 1.0; Earth Love United selections, conversions, and transformations identified.", "limitations": "2024 territorial fossil CO2 values are source estimates; fossil and land-use series remain separate." }, { "id": "wpp", "source_registry_id": "un-wpp-2024", "ai_reviewed_publication_decision": "allow_with_attribution", "licence_basis": "United Nations World Population Prospects 2024 under CC BY 3.0 IGO.", "required_attribution": "United Nations DESA Population Division (2024), World Population Prospects 2024; Earth Love United selected the 2024 Medium projection and converted thousands to persons.", "limitations": "The 2024 Medium value is a modeled projection denominator, not an observed census count." }, { "id": "ember", "source_registry_id": "ember-yearly-electricity-data-2026-08-25", "ai_reviewed_publication_decision": "allow_with_attribution", "licence_basis": "Ember Yearly Electricity Data and API under CC BY 4.0.", "required_attribution": "Ember, Yearly Electricity Data, full release retrieved 2026-08-25; Earth Love United selections and transformations identified.", "limitations": "Published actual-year evidence classes and Ember's generation-fuel taxonomy are preserved; blank values remain gaps." }, { "id": "cckp_cmip6", "source_registry_id": "world-bank-cckp-cmip6-2026-08-24", "ai_reviewed_publication_decision": "allow_with_attribution", "licence_basis": "World Bank Climate Change Knowledge Portal processed CMIP6 data under CC BY 4.0.", "required_attribution": "World Bank CCKP; WCRP CMIP6 modeling groups and ESGF acknowledged; Earth Love United scenario, period, percentile, and transformation choices identified.", "limitations": "2040–2059 country aggregates are modeled anomalies relative to 1995–2014; ranges are not probabilistic forecasts." }, { "id": "cckp_era5", "source_registry_id": "world-bank-cckp-era5-2026-08-25", "ai_reviewed_publication_decision": "allow_with_attribution", "licence_basis": "World Bank CCKP processed ERA5 country aggregates under CC BY 4.0 with underlying ERA5/Copernicus attribution retained.", "required_attribution": "World Bank CCKP and ERA5/Copernicus; Earth Love United 1970–2025 selection and OLS trends per decade identified.", "limitations": "ERA5 is reanalysis, not station observation; annual precipitation is an area-mean accumulation and not a drought or runoff measure." } ], "globe_asset_decisions": [ { "path": "assets/globe/runtime/manifest.json", "decision": "exclude", "reason": "The legacy five-asset manifest describes assets that are deliberately absent from this exact public lane." }, { "path": "assets/globe/runtime/night-sky.png", "decision": "exclude", "reason": "Underlying example-image rights were not established." }, { "path": "assets/globe/runtime/earth-blue-marble.jpg", "decision": "exclude", "reason": "Underlying example-image rights were not established." }, { "path": "assets/globe/runtime/earth-topology.png", "decision": "exclude", "reason": "Underlying example-image rights were not established." }, { "path": "assets/globe/runtime/ne_110m_admin_0_countries.geojson", "decision": "retain_with_attribution_and_limits", "basis": "Natural Earth public-domain terms.", "limits": "Generalized navigation geometry only; no sovereignty or legal-boundary claim; approximate points for some small nations." }, { "path": "assets/globe/runtime/earth-night.jpg", "decision": "retain_with_attribution_and_limits", "basis": "Exact bytes traced to NASA Earth Observatory Black Marble 2012 and used with source/data credit.", "limits": "Historical decorative surface only; no current-climate-data or endorsement claim." } ], "condition_resolutions": [ { "id": "exclude_ambiguous_globe_images", "status": "resolved", "evidence": "The 51-file allowlist excludes the three image paths and legacy manifest; negative checks reject paths, hashes, URLs, and executable tokens." }, { "id": "correct_public_globe_attribution", "status": "resolved", "evidence": "The staged page states that Three-Globe example images are excluded and describes the retained NASA surface as historical/decorative with no endorsement implied." }, { "id": "retain_source_attribution_and_transformations", "status": "resolved", "evidence": "GCB, WPP, Ember, CCKP CMIP6, and CCKP ERA5 licence bases, source roles, changes, and limitations remain in public and machine-readable evidence." }, { "id": "precise_ai_review_label", "status": "resolved", "evidence": "Public page, interactive UI, fallback, and this artifact state source-data evidence classes and deny human review and legal certification." }, { "id": "remove_evaluative_outputs", "status": "resolved", "evidence": "No target, finance, score, grade, offset, mismatched-scope, or performance output is enabled; order remains same-metric magnitude only." }, { "id": "disable_inverted_carbon_relief", "status": "resolved", "evidence": "The public transform removes the query token, fixes higher values to higher relief, and the verifier rejects regressions." }, { "id": "preserve_human_gate", "status": "resolved", "evidence": "The existing eight-role production release package and globe-asset signature trust remain absent/unprovisioned and fail closed; the AI lane is separately routed." }, { "id": "deterministic_stage_and_rollback", "status": "resolved", "evidence": "The exact 51-file stage, four deterministic transforms, 249-entity rollback snapshot, cache epoch, and strict aggregate dispatch are independently verified." }, { "id": "four_ai_reports_three_model_families", "status": "resolved", "evidence": "Two Luna, one Terra, and one Sol report are complete, exactly pinned, and bound to the same canonical subject digest and review-request SHA." } ], "artifact_pins": [ { "path": ".github/CODEOWNERS", "sha256": "eb5032a791d8a2f9674ab34481086f1d0827a4decd3a446ee0b667b77e8d4302" }, { "path": ".github/workflows/ci.yml", "sha256": "71202487085c25c9ef3bfb5818045561bcb55391892532cc13eaacf122052d73" }, { "path": "ARCHITECTURE.md", "sha256": "ab5000ac86dfe98afaea9d158c25189d995d0f79c3f5988d104e6988644c18fe" }, { "path": "CREDITS.md", "sha256": "31968896e4e5cad9b2614373a3a15d799beab21bb384b8ae8f7fabbe8f6edc4b" }, { "path": "THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.txt", "sha256": "741fc18dfd4b0916884cbad6b4dddd3466b7e2399186e5dcd7ff555e482fd0f2" }, { "path": "assets/globe/runtime/earth-night.jpg", "sha256": "373e5a08c9f378a2ce6320214a613148e4b1e3946b3f39a516c9093b76cb7124" }, { "path": "assets/globe/runtime/ne_110m_admin_0_countries.geojson", "sha256": "a4d67eac9c75d5b6f20170d2b07bb53ea791536b0c8e5ebae3ba94df093f76e0" }, { "path": "data/climate/releases/country-climate-intelligence-v1/release-manifest.json", "sha256": "e7674a0c338a22d1b2e891cfa54a47361a4a9cc935361a816332074afd7c1aa1" }, { "path": "data/climate/releases/country-climate-intelligence-v1/review-request.json", "sha256": "0904afc65386a570871fdc77262a8beb6da8f19043a3d1f235edefd4f96d0372" }, { "path": "data/climate/reviews/country-climate-intelligence-v1-multi-model-ai-prepublication-review.json", "sha256": "0b31ad40c5a42cad33d641d2a0d87e009322e5efb6b7dcee33f0f4d7fef69adc" }, { "path": "data/climate/runtime/country-climate-intelligence.json", "sha256": "4939fbc6e26c0ef0fc283ecf98ab3924ccb93d93b7e5392eab2014f7ab3c57fe" }, { "path": "data/climate/source-registry.json", "sha256": "6b9e468096ffd073966dea5cc5c6cea6fdffea3c3ab03e78dd31fdf629cf4eba" }, { "path": "tools/build-cci-factual-public-deploy.sh", "sha256": "2ed46b95e96b4d5100eaf59576351963370db01d5d9a020dc67a374bae93dec6" }, { "path": "tools/check-cci-factual-public-deploy.js", "sha256": "cd09eed85f8484300baf15ad129f3bc9f37595ded11ec736f401eff70931ccd4" }, { "path": "tools/check-cci-factual-public-review.js", "sha256": "e95beb2ad6a1edde2316e8587dce0c32ca029e19625a552ad3ef54fdaff58b04" }, { "path": "tools/check-public-climate-release-profile.js", "sha256": "2221675b776616155716e713569e5b3892d8f494fd7ef7377db3d0c7fb6b5b8f" }, { "path": "tools/check-staged-cci-factual-public-integrity.js", "sha256": "a703815dd3e33f2e44787eb12813fdb0834fc1f7b1d53c04214964eda7a0e51b" }, { "path": "tools/check-staged-production-integrity.js", "sha256": "fd3ac6a54213c3e07d0c1363ae42f1180340554f1964fddfa29838cdc15e9221" }, { "path": "tools/fixtures/globe-runtime-assets.json", "sha256": "3757af12953a80260d49edf89ff1887709b6237ca1bb52f46dd4046f53a1b1a4" }, { "path": "tools/fixtures/globe-third-party-notices.json", "sha256": "9d1160d59c15b061126c8cd351572d7dd0aef85e4b83292af17fd4d6e6ab9c92" }, { "path": "tools/lib/cci-factual-public.js", "sha256": "c49a355e197e3370ae0f29283b336aa1deea28f3edb325246473018a7a94c613" }, { "path": "tools/lib/globe-runtime-assets.js", "sha256": "e0236a7d049c9e9f2efa8bdf688056dbfc3974faee7858445985723dffa9dea3" }, { "path": "tools/prepare-country-climate-intelligence-review-request.js", "sha256": "68f050e6f09029932e8513236350b145eac68913d4e14ac28d56bd106071be6e" }, { "path": "tools/stage-cci-factual-public-deploy.js", "sha256": "8c283fd84cd608ae75a6eb27f7f36d5d184d80c270c6aafb7b36384597ff29fe" } ], "public_output_pins": [ { "path": "THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.txt", "sha256": "741fc18dfd4b0916884cbad6b4dddd3466b7e2399186e5dcd7ff555e482fd0f2" }, { "path": "assets/globe/runtime/earth-night.jpg", "sha256": "373e5a08c9f378a2ce6320214a613148e4b1e3946b3f39a516c9093b76cb7124" }, { "path": "assets/globe/runtime/ne_110m_admin_0_countries.geojson", "sha256": "a4d67eac9c75d5b6f20170d2b07bb53ea791536b0c8e5ebae3ba94df093f76e0" }, { "path": "data/climate/runtime/country-climate-intelligence.json", "sha256": "4939fbc6e26c0ef0fc283ecf98ab3924ccb93d93b7e5392eab2014f7ab3c57fe" }, { "path": "index.html", "sha256": "d3eddf0726717464091d285cbd516babe8a114cdedce727c9af46cb68c4a9227" }, { "path": "js/country-climate-intelligence.js", "sha256": "e4ebdf2afb1f7662d04e8a371c0bb6587cd7eedcdeec21c105212073aa02cac8" }, { "path": "js/globe.js", "sha256": "9620c953112b7db0305ca7b0242e344d9c0ec4cea912480b7480fb776597edc6" }, { "path": "js/vendor/globe.gl.js", "sha256": "2ab6767f47e2be0ac346cd7a5eb55d259ea3da06d479dc22f1820ddd698f496a" }, { "path": "sw.js", "sha256": "b49c237a06f699352d7637e8cca87d80cc4d17f9740401bd94f120803627118b" } ], "known_limitations": [ "This is four AI reviews across three model families, not four institutions and not human scientific review.", "Country-level uncertainty is unavailable for several inputs; CMIP6 spread is shown, while ERA5 OLS trend uncertainty is not propagated.", "Some upstream raw sources are referenced by exact external receipts rather than archived in this repository.", "A standalone legacy source-routing snapshot checker has pre-existing source-registry hash drift; CCI-specific checks and the canonical request pin the current registry bytes.", "Cloudflare production status is an operational post-merge requirement and is not implied by this review artifact." ], "calculation_hash": "6e8de4b102aefb8ec904689ecadd56a6131fbabb8d90838ec85bfad14fa9c84a" }